Daniel FloresCOMPASS · DRE# 02032133 415 · 596 · 1891
Home → Journal
THE JOURNAL

San Francisco Overbids Hit $10 Million Over Asking. Then This Week Happened.

By Daniel Flores · Compass · San Francisco & Marin · November 18, 2026

San Francisco's 2026 housing market has been defined by overbids, some of them historic. But this month a handful of the city's most expensive sales told a different story: three homes priced at or near $19 million traded at or below their asking prices in November. Here is what changed, why the top of the market tends to move first, and what it means if you plan to sell in San Francisco or Marin in the year ahead.

The overbid ladder San Francisco sellers climbed in 2026

If you own a home in San Francisco, you have heard the stories this year. A 1914 house on a Lake Street cul-de-sac, 2 6th Avenue, was listed in September at $8 million and sold in October for $15 million, 87 percent over asking. A Cow Hollow listing went $2.7 million over list after professional staging. Then on Cherry Street in Presidio Heights, an eight-bedroom home listed at $18.5 million sold for $28.5 million, a $10 million overbid that set a city record.

The data behind the anecdotes is just as striking. According to a Sotheby's International Realty market report cited by The Real Deal, 87 percent of San Francisco homes sold above their asking price in the third quarter of 2026, and in September homes sold for an average of 131 percent of list.

The sale that broke the pattern

On Thursday, November 12, 3385 Jackson Street, a 6,835-square-foot, five-bedroom home a few blocks from that record-setting Cherry Street sale, closed for $18.8 million. It had been listed on October 12 at $18,750,000. Thirty-one days on market, and a sale essentially at asking. The seller was a trust; the home last traded in 2015 for $13.5 million.

It was not alone. On November 2, the roughly 9,650-square-foot mansion at 2090 Vallejo Street in Pacific Heights sold for $19.5 million after listing in mid-September at $25 million, nearly 22 percent below asking. The same week, 1281 Greenwich Street in Russian Hill sold for exactly its $19.5 million list price after 117 days on the market, in a neighborhood where homes had been selling in about three weeks.

Why the top of the market cools first

Luxury buyers are the most rate-sensitive and the most stock-market-sensitive buyers in the city, and they have the most alternatives. When three $19 million-plus homes in a row trade at or below asking, it does not mean the Sunset is about to see price cuts next week. It does mean that the margin for mispricing has gotten thinner, and that trend historically works its way down the price ladder over a few quarters.

It also tells you something about how the big overbids happened in the first place. The sellers who got $7 million or $10 million over asking did not list high and hope. They priced where the buyers already were, sometimes deliberately below the obvious comp, and they prepared the house before launch. The SF Standard reported this month that one staging firm's three most recent San Francisco sales closed in under two weeks at an average of 81.5 percent over asking.

What this means if you are selling in 2027

First, do not price to the headline. The $28.5 million Cherry Street sale is a comp for almost no one, and buyers know it. Second, invest in preparation before the first photo, not after the first price reduction. Third, pay attention to days on market in your own neighborhood over the next 90 days. If homes that used to sell in two weeks start taking five, the market is telling you something the headlines have not caught up to.

I track these numbers weekly for sellers across San Francisco and Marin. If you want to know where your home sits right now, not where the September average says it should, reach out and I will run the comps for your block.

Sources: The Real Deal, "Home at SF's geographic center hits market after full rebuild," Nov 15, 2026; The Real Deal, "Resi cooling trend? Two SF homes near $20M each with no overbid," Nov 2, 2026; SFGate via Yahoo Finance, "SF home sells for $7M over asking," Oct 7, 2026; NBC Bay Area, Oct 26, 2026; Redfin listing history for 3385 Jackson St; SF Standard, "SF's red-hot real estate market means a gold rush for luxury home stagers," Nov 8, 2026.

Wondering what your San Francisco home is worth?

Not a Zestimate — a real valuation from a Top 1% agent with 19+ years across lending, title, and brokerage. Personal, fast, no obligation.

Get My Home Value → Text Daniel